Breaking it up ruins it completely for the people who use shuffle.

Well, but who does?

Or, put differently: people who use shuffle are ruining the album's impact anyway already, so why bother?

Shuffle no good, some albums should be listened to as an album so I've stopped the ways of the shuffler.

Terria for example, its wrong if you shuffle it. Pink Floyd too, its just... wrong.

Each to their own though.